Parallel Structure Error Found In Students

Parallel Structure Error Found In Students

a research proposal that may be can be an inspiration for finish the study as an English students

CHAPTER I

INTRODUCTION

A.    Background of the Problem
There are four skills that should be mastered by students in learning English. They are listening, speaking, reading, and writing that interrelated each other. Moreover, they are mutually supporting each other and should not be treated discreetly. For example, when learners want to improve their writing skill, they have to read voraciously. By reading voraciously they will get many inspirations and materials for their writing.
Writing is the most important skill among these four skills because it trains the writer’s brain to be more active. By writing writer would try hard to express their ideas, feeling and information. According to Rita in Erza (2012:1) written language is used to communicate with others, to get things done, to provide information and to entertain.
There are some ways to express the ideas in writing. They are through writing sentence, paragraph, and essay. First, sentence. According to Oshima and Hogue (1999:21) a sentence is a group of words that is used to communicate the ideas in writing or speech. It means that sentences start from subject, predicate, and then followed immediately by adverb or object complements. Second, paragraph. Oshima and Hogue in page 3 state that a paragraph is a basic unit of organization in writing which is a group of related sentences develops one main idea. Third, essay. Oshima and Hogue in page 77 also say that essay is a piece of writing several paragraph long instead of just one or two paragraphs.
To be specific, in writing an essay someone must consider some essential parts of essay like introductory paragraph, body of paragraphs, and concluding paragraph. In addition, Oshima and Hogue (1999:101) explain that there are three main parts of essay. They are an introductory paragraph, body of paragraphs (at least one, but usually two or more paragraphs) and a concluding paragraph. The introductory paragraph consists of two parts.  They are general statement and thesis statement. Bodies of paragraphs consist of a number of subdivisions or subtopic that is developed from topic. The body of paragraph is usually the longest part of essay. And then, the concluding paragraph is a summary or review of the main point discussed in the body paragraph.
Related to the explanation above, Thornburry in Romi (2012:1) states that there are some errors that often made by the writer in writing. They are lexical errors, grammatical errors, and discourse errors. First lexical errors include mistakes in which the words are combined. Second, grammatical errors cover such as mistakes in verb, tense form and sentence structure. The last one is discourse errors. These errors related to the way of sentences are organized and linked in order to make a whole text.
Parallel structure is one kind of grammatical errors. It is an important thing that should be mastered by the writer, especially when the writer is listing, comparing and contrasting items or ideas. Then, Tyner (1996:371) states that there are some advantages of parallel structure in writing. It can make writing product smoother, clearer and easier for readers to understand. Next, Oshima (1999:166) states that parallel structure means that each item in a list or comparison follows the same grammatical pattern. For instance, when the writer wants to make a list and the first item in her/his list is a noun, so the writer has to make all of the following items in noun also.
Parallel structure consists of parallel in a series or list, parallel with ideas presented as pairs and parallel with verb tenses. Parallel in a series or list means that all of the items should keep the same grammatical form. Then, parallel with ideas presented as pairs is when connecting two independent clauses, and independent clause and phrase, and independent clause and dependent clause. The grammatical structure should remain the same in both pairs. And parallel with verb tenses means that verb tenses in a sentence should remain the same grammatical form.
The fourth semester students of STAIN Batusangkar 2011/2012 academic year has taken Writing IV subject. They have learnt essay. The students of this semester have studied the essay pattern and some organizations of essay. It means that they have learnt how to construct a good essay based on its organization included the essay with comparison and contrast organization.
The researcher has done the preliminary research on September 15th 2012. It was done by collecting the fourth semester of English department students’ writing midterm test. Based on the researcher’s observation, the students still had some difficulties in order to make a good essay. They are students were still difficult in making a good sentence structure included choice of words, the use of correct tenses, and the use of conjunctions.
The next error made by students is in making good parallel structure in their essay. For example, students made a sentence “My sister and I have some hobbies, for example cooking together, watching televisions, and plant flowers in front of house.” It is not a correct parallel structure at all. The first two elements, cooking together and watching television are in parallel structure because both are gerund. The third one, plant flower ruins the parallel structure because it is in the infinitive form. The correct one has to be ”My sister and I have the same hobbies, for example watching televisions, cooking together, and planting flowers in front of house.”
Based on the explanation previously, the researcher is interested in conducting a research related to the problems found in students’ essay of the fourth semester students of English department of STAIN Batusangkar in 2011/2012 academic year.
B.     Identification of the Problem
Based on the background of the problem previously, it can be identified the problem as follows:
1.      The students had difficulties in order to make good sentence structure.
2.      The students are difficult in choosing the suitable words.
3.      The students are difficult in using correct tenses.
4.      The students are difficult in using the correct conjunction.
5.      The students still made errors in making parallel structure errors in their essay.
C.    Limitation and Formulation of the Problem
Based on the identification of the problem above, the researcher will limit the problem with the students’ parallelism errors in writing essay. The general problem is formulated in the following question: “What is the parallel structure error found in students’ essay of the fourth semester students of English department of STAIN Batusangkar in 2011/2012 academic year.”

D.    Definition of Key Term
In order to avoid misunderstanding in this research, the researcher defines some key terms as follow:
1.      Parallel structure means that each item should follow the same grammatical patterns.
2.      Essay is a piece of writing several paragraphs that written by the fourth semester students of English Department of STAIN Batusangkar in 2011/2012 academic year.
E.     Purpose of the Research
The purpose of this research is to describe the parallelism errors found in students’ essay by the fourth semester students of English department of STAIN Batusangkar in 2011/2012 academic year.
F.     Significant of the Research
The result of this research is expected to give the useful information especially for:
1.      Students
The results of this research are expected to give understanding for students about the correct use of parallel structure so that they can avoid errors in making parallel structure in their essay.

2.      Lectures
The lecturers know more about the common errors made by students in their writing especially parallelism errors. By this research the lectures are expected to give more comprehension to the students about parallel structure errors in their writing.
3.      Researcher
The researcher will find out the common errors made by students in their writing especially in writing essay. This research is also as one of the requirement in writing V subject.












CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

A.    Review of Relevant Theories
1.      Writing
a.      The Nature of Writing
Writing is one way to communicate with the other people. It is done by produce language in written form. Someone may express her/his ideas, thoughts, and feelings through writing, and writing also helps to understand and comprehend ideas.
Oshima and Hogue in Romi (2012:11) state that writing is a cognitive and learning experience that helps someone to find out what he or she wants to say. It means that writing can help someone to think critically. It is valuable in learning about people, events or things. Then, Oxford Dictionary (2005:480) explains that writing is activity of writing, written or printed words.
Moreover, Meyers (2005:2) explains that writing is speaking to other on paper or on a computer screen. It means that writing is communication in written form.  Writing is partly a talent, but it is mostly a skill. Writing is also an action or process of discovering and organizing the writer’s ideas and putting them on the paper, reshaping and revising them.
Bell and Burnaby in Nunan (1999:39) state that writing is an extremely complex cognitive activity in which the writer is required to demonstrate control of a number of variables simultaneously. The control includes content, format, sentence structure, vocabulary, punctuation, spelling, and letter formation.
Based on the explanation above, it can be defined that writing is as a cognitive and learning experience. It is one way to communicate with others in written form which someone can express her/his ideas, thoughts, and feelings through writing. Writing also helps to understand and comprehend ideas.
b.      The Importance of Writing
Writing is one of the most important skills in English that should be mastered by learner. Someone can communicate with other, share her/his ideas or feelings and express something deals with what he or she wants to express. According to Chappell in Romi (2012:12), there are some reasons why writing is important. They are:
1)      Writing is the primary basis upon which the writer works, the writer learning, and the writer intellect will be judged in school or college, in the workplace, and in the community.
2)      Writing expresses who the writer is as a person.
3)      Writing is portable and permanent. It makes the writer’s thinking visible.
4)      Writing helps writer moves easily among facts, inferences, and opinions without getting confused and without confusing the readers.
5)      Writing promotes writer’s ability to pose worthwhile question.
6)      Writing fosters writer’s ability in explaining a complex position to readers and to her/his self.
7)      Writing helps others give the writer feedback.
8)      Writing helps the writer refines her/his ideas when she/he given others feedback.
9)      Writing requires that writer anticipate her/his reader’s need. S/he is able to do so demonstrate her/his intellectual flexibility and maturity.
10)  Writing ideas down preserves them so that the writer can reflect upon them later.
11)  Writing outs writer’s ideas permits the writer to evaluate the adequacy of her/his argument.
12)  Writing stimulates writer to extend a line of thought beyond her/his first impression or good responses.
13)  Writing helps writer understand how truth is established in a given discipline.
14)  Writing equips writer with the communication and thinking skills s/he needs to participate effectively in democracy.
15)  Writing is an essential job skill.   

Based on the expert’s opinion above, the researcher can conclude that writing is really important to be mastered by the learner. It is important in all of the aspect of life and it can give many advantages especially in communicating with other people, sharing ideas or feeling, and giving information.
c.       The Purpose of Writing
Writing has many purposes. The writer writes something depends on what her/his wants. For example, someone writes an article or journal to persuade the reader or just to explain something. According to Rozakis (2003:188), there are four purposes in writing. Those purposes are as follow:
1)      To explain: manuals, term papers, textbooks, articles, news stories.
2)      To persuade: critical reviews, resumes, job evaluations speeches.
3)      To describe: poems, journals.
4)      To tell a story: autobiographies, anecdotes, short stories, novels.

d.      Elements of Good Writing
Writing is not an easy job. When the writer tries to write something, she or he must consider many things. There are several elements that should be known by the writer in order to make a good writing. Blanchard and Root (2004:5-8) explain that there are three elements of good writing. They are as follow:
1)      Subject
In order to write well, the writer has to choose a topic that interesting and understandable. When the writer is assigned a subject, he/she must try to find an angle of focus of subject.  The writer must go through a process of narrowing down the general subject until the writer fined an appropriate topic.



2)      Purpose
When somebody write something, it is important to think about her/his purpose. The three most common purposes for writing are to entertain, to inform, and to persuade. And then, in order to determine the purpose, the writer should ask her/himself the question, “Why am I writing?” 
3)      Audience
Audience is the next elements in good writing. Because the writer will usually be writing for an audience, the writer will communicate her/his ideas more effectively if he or she keeps audience in mind.
Based on the explanation above, the writer can draw a conclusion that there are three elements of good writing. These three elements should be considered by writer in order to achieve good writing.
2.      Essay
a.      Definition of Essay
Oshima and Hogue (1999:100) state that an essay is constructed in several paragraphs long instead of just one or two paragraphs. It develops one topic just like developing a paragraph. However the topic of an essay is too complex to discuss in one paragraph. Then, Reid states that essay is a series of paragraphs about one topic; each paragraph has specific function.
Blanchard and Root in Romi (2012:18) state that an essay is a group of paragraphs about a specific subject. It is like a paragraph; an essay makes and supports one main point. Mostly, a typical essay contains five paragraphs, but many others types of essays are longer or shorter, depending on their purpose.
In addition, Meyers (2005:38) states that essay is an organized discussion of a subject in a series of paragraphs. A paragraph and an essay actually share many traits. In an essay is not simply a longer version of a paragraph. The content of the essay in more complex and needs more development.
From the theories above, the researcher can conclude that essay is a series of paragraph that has one topic, and it is more complex than paragraph. An essay may be longer or shorter in length.
b.      Part of essay
According to Meyers (2005:38), an essay consists of three main parts, namely introductory paragraph, body of paragraph and concluding paragraph. They are as follow:
1)      Introductory Paragraph
Introductory paragraph is the first paragraph of the essay. It attracts the readers’ interest, makes the primary claim of the essay in a thesis statement, and may introduce the ideas of the body paragraph.
2)      Body of Paragraph
Body paragraph at least has three paragraphs and more often. It develops and supports the thesis by breaking it down into smaller ideas.
3)      Concluding Paragraph
Concluding paragraph is the last paragraph of the essay. It ties all the essay’s ideas together and includes a strong ending and usually restates the thesis and summarizes the main idea.
To make clear the explanation above, the diagram below will explain about the parts of an essay. They are as follow:

Introductory Paragraph: creates reader interest and states the main idea while including
An attention getter
A thesis statement
A preview of the body
Each Body Paragraph (usually at least three) develop the main idea
Develops one supporting idea of the thesis
Usually states the idea in a topic sentence
Then develops the idea
Ends with a transition to the next paragraph
Concluding Paragraph: closes the essay
Usually restates the thesis and summarizes the main idea
Ends with a strong statement
                                                                                          (Meyers 2005:39)

3.      Parallel Structure
a.      Definition of Parallel Structure
Parallel structure is one of the most important things in writing because it can help the writing style clearness and readability. Parallel structure may be known also as parallelism or parallel construction. The principle of parallel structure is a simple one. Plainly put, the reader expects consistency. Ideas that are related each other should be expressed in parallel form. Expressions similar in content and function should be expressed similarly.
In addition, parallel structure concerns the balance of sentences, or the similarity of words, phrases, or clauses in a list or series. Then, Parallel structure means that every item in a list or comparison follows the same grammatical pattern (Oshima and Hogue 1999:166). Then, Reid in Romi (2012:25) explains that:
“Parallel structure is the repetition not just of ideas but also of grammatical structures and grammatical function. These structures can be simple (such as a repetition of a series of single related nouns), or more complex (such as a repetition of a series of phrases, clauses, or complete sentence structures).”

Based on the experts’ explanation previously, the researcher can conclude that parallel structure is the way to make a list or comparison follows the same grammatical form. It may be indicated as a kind of consistent repetition.
b.      Types of Parallel Structure
According to Gerald in Romi (2012:27), there are three types of parallel structure. They are as follow:
1)      Parallel Structure with Ideas Presented as Pairs
The grammatical structure should remain the same in both pairs when connecting two independent clauses, an independent clause and phrase, and an independent clause and dependent clause. There are three ways to parallel them. They are:
a)      Using a coordination conjunction (FANBOYS): For, And, Nor, But, Or, Yet, So. The example of correct parallel structure can be seen in this sentence: Tutors are finding (verb-ing) ways to improve their workshops and creating (verb-ing) ways to increase students’ retention of the material. Then, the faulty parallel structure can be seen in this example: Tutors are finding (verb-ing) ways to improve their workshops and create (not verb-ing) ways to increase students’ retention of the material.     
b)      Using correlative conjunctions: either, not only, but also, etc.
When connecting two ideas using either/or, neither/nor, not only/but also, both/and, and whether/or, the second part of the pair should have the same grammatical structure. The correct parallel structure can be seen in this example: The movie I saw last night was not only too long but also too violent. Then, the faulty parallel structure is like this sentence: The movie I saw was not only too long but was also extremely violent.


c)      Using a word introducing a comparison: Than
When using than, the items compared should be grammatically parallel. The example of the faulty parallel structure is: It is easier to lead a simple existence than questioning your programmed beliefs. And the correct one is: It is easier to lead (infinitive form) a simple existence than to question (infinitive form) your programmed beliefs.
2)      Parallel Structure in a Series or List
In a series or list, all of the items should keep the same grammatical form. When the writer wants to make a list and the first item in her/his list is a verb, the writer should make all of the following items as verb also. The faulty parallel structure can be seen in this example: “He has good personality like: cheerful (adjective), friendly (adjective), honesty (noun), and optimistic (adjective)”. Then, the correct parallel structure can be seen in this following example: “He has good personality like: cheerful (adjective), friendly (adjective), honest (adjective), and optimistic (adjective)”.
3)      Parallel Structure with Verb Tenses
The writer also has to make the parallel structure in verb tenses. The correct parallel structure in verb tenses can be seen in this example: I walked (past tense) home from work on Friday, so I picked (past tense) up food from a stand near my house. Next, the faulty example of verb tenses can be seen in this sentence: I walked (past tense) home from work on Friday, so I pick (present tense) up food from a stand near my house.
4.      Error
a.      Definition of Errors
Errors are something that commonly happened in a writing process, because writing is not an easy one. People cannot be a good writer without first systematically committing errors. According to Dulay in Nina (2005:13), errors are the flawed side of learner speech or writing. Making errors is an inevitable part of learning. In addition, as Porte in Nina (2005:13) said, errors demonstrate a deeper level of a fault of the learner. Errors may have become so ingrained that the learner may not even have perceived it as errors. 
Another definition of error is defined by Teh in Amelia (2004:38) who points out that the word errors is used to refer to a form of structure that a native speaker deems unacceptable or the use of linguistic item in a way in which or fluent native speaker of the language incomplete learning. So the learner have to concern with structure of a language that used by native speaker in order to avoid errors.
Moreover, it is crucial to make a distinction between errors and mistakes. It is because many learners are taught that errors and mistakes are two things that similar. To avoid misunderstanding about errors and mistakes, the researcher will explain a distinction between them.
According to Brown (2000:217), a mistake refers to a performance error that is either a random guess or a “slip”, in that it is a failure to use system correctly, while an error is a noticeable deviation from the adult grammar of a native speaker, reflecting the inter-language competence of the learner.
From the explanation above, the researcher makes a conclusion that errors are something that often happens to learner and it caused by incomplete knowledge about something. Error done regularly while a mistake done because of the fault and happen regularly.
b.      Types of Errors
Thornbury in Wilfa (2004:114) explains there are three types of errors. They are lexical errors, grammatical errors and discourse errors. First, lexical errors which include mistakes in the words are combined. It can be seen in this example: the Wednesday afternoon past instead of last Wednesday afternoon. Second, grammar errors that cover such things as mistakes in verb, form, tense and in sentence structure. Third, discourse errors that relate to the way sentences are organized and linked in order to make whole text.
In addition, it is crucial to make the types of grammatical errors in this research because in this research focusing on analyzing the parallel structure that belongs to grammatical errors. According to Dulay in Nina (2005:19), there are some types of grammatical errors, they are:
1)      Omission Errors
Omission errors are characterized by the absence of an item that must appear in a well-formed sentence. It can be seen in this example: I student Elementary School number 5 Batusangkar. Some items that omitted are: am, a, at.
2)      Addition Errors
Addition errors are the opposite of omissions. They are characterized by the presence of an item that must not appear in a well-formed utterance. It can be seen in this following example: She does not goes to school.
3)      Misinformation Errors
Misinformation errors are characterized by the use of the wrong form of the morpheme or structure. In misinformation errors the learner supplies something, although it is incorrect. It can be seen in this example: The cat eated the fish.
4)      Disordering Errors
Disordering errors are characterized by the incorrect placement of a morpheme or group of morphemes in an utterance. It can be seen in this following example: What Daddy is doing?
It is clear that, there are three types of errors that often found by the learner. They are lexical errors, grammatical errors and discourse errors.
B.     Review of Relevant Studies
Based on the literatures that have read, the researcher found two relevant studies related to the research topic. The first study is written by Ilyas entitle “An Analysis of Grammatical Errors Found in Recount Text Written by the Students (A Study of Tenth Year Students of SMAN I Sungai Tarab Registered 2010/2011 Academic Year). The results of his research are the students still made errors in writing recount text. The errors are in using pronoun, writing temporal conjunction and writing simple past tense that include errors omission of using –ed, additional to be, selection of irregular and regular verb, selection of did and not after subject and omission of using were/was.
This study is relevant with the previous research because both of them discuss the way of writing based on grammatical rules. The difference is the previous research discuss about errors in using appropriate grammar in writing recount text while the recent research analyzes the parallel structure errors in students’ essay.
The second study found by the researcher is a study written by Fitri Yenty (2011) entitles An Analysis of Grammatical Errors Found in the Letters of Complaint Made by Students (a Study of the Sixth Students of English Department of STAIN Batusangkar 2010/2011 Academic Year). The result of her research is the students still made grammatical errors in writing letters of complaint. It was in misinformation in using noun, verb, to be, have, and misinformation in using the form of future tense.
This study is relevant with the previous research because both of them discuss the way of writing based on grammatical rules. It is also about the grammatical errors. The difference is the previous research discuss about errors in writing letters of complaint while the recent research analyzes the parallel structure errors in students’ essay.
C.    Conceptual Frame Work
There are some kind of grammatical errors that made by students in their writing. They are verbs tense errors, parallelism errors, conjunction errors, and using noun errors. In this research the researcher focuses in analyzing parallel structure errors found in students’ essay. The researcher wants to know what parallel structure error is made by the fourth semester students of English department of STAIN Batusangkar 2011/2012 academic year.
To make the reader easy to understand the conceptual framework, the researcher makes a chart as follows:
Students Writing
Analysis
Essay
Grammatical Errors
Parallelism Errors
Result
 

















CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
A.    Research Design
This research is about parallel structure errors found in students’ essay. It is conducted through quantitative approach. According to Gay (2000:11), studies designed to describe current conditions are referred to descriptive research. It involves collecting data in order to answer the questions about the current status of the subject or topic of study. It means that a descriptive research try to give a description on how the way things are. In this research the researcher describe parallel structure errors found in students’ essay of English department students of STAIN Batusangkar 2011/2012 academic year.
B.     Population and Sample
1.    Population
The population of this research is all of the fourth semester students of English department of STAIN Batusangkar 2011/2012 academic year. It is about 100 students from class A, B and C. According to Gay and Peter (2000:122) population is the group which the researcher is interested to conduct his/her research toward that group. Then the result of the research could be generalized into that group. Purwanto (2010:219) also states that population is a group of individual who has the general and same characteristic. The fourth semester students A, B and C of English department of STAIN Batusangkar 2011/2012 academic year has the same characteristic because they have taken Writing IV and learnt essay include its organization.
2.      Sample
According to Purwanto (2010:220) sample is a part of population which represents the characteristic of the population. In addition, Soenarto (1987:2) also states that sample is a part of population selected based on the right way of sampling so that sample may represent the population. The selection of sample should be done correctly based on the way of sampling to take a good quality of sample.
Sample of this research is 80 students of English department of STAIN Batusangkar 2011/2012 academic year. Gay (2000:134) state that for 100 or fewer population sizes, the sample sizes required are 80. It based on the formulation developed by the United States Offices of Education in Gay (2000:133). The way to take sample is proportionate random sampling. The researcher chooses 80 of 100 students randomly based on the level of students’ ability.


C.    Technique of Data Collection
1.      Research Instrument
The research instrument in this research will be the test. Each of students will make an essay based on comparison and contrast pattern. Then, the researcher will collect the data or document. After getting the data, the researcher will try to analyze what is parallel structure errors found in student’s essay.
In addition, the researcher has to consider validity and reliability of the data. Gay (2000: 161) defines validity is the degree to which a test measures what is supposed to measure, consequently permits appropriate interpretations of test scores. It is the most important quality of a test. In other words, Brown (2004:22) explains that validity is the extent to which inferences made from assessment results are appropriate, meaningful, and useful in terms of the purpose of the assessment.
Then, the most important thing of the data is reliability. According to Brown (2004:20), a reliable test is consistent and dependable. Then, Gay (2000:169) states that reliability is the degree to which a test consistently measures whatever it measures. Therefore, to make the data reliable, the researcher will analyze them repeatedly (twice) and will consult with both advisors in order to get the final valid result.

2.      Research Procedures
This research will be conducted by applying the following steps. They are preparation, operation and post operation.
a.     Preparation
1)      Focusing on one problem that researcher interest in.
2)      Collecting the sources and references that related on the research.
3)      Preparing and writing the research proposal.
4)      Consulting the paper with lecturer
5)      Revising the paper.
b.      Operation
In operating, the researcher will conduct a test making an essay.
c.       Post Operation
1)      Analyzing the data.
2)      Drawing conclusion.
3)      Interpreting the data.
D.    Technique of  Data Analysis
In analyzing the data, the researcher will use the descriptive analysis. In this case, the following steps will carry out:
1.    Analyzing the Data
a.    Collecting the data
b.    Coding of data collection
c.    Omitting students’ proposal  name
d.   Underlining the inconsistency in the use of pronoun by students
e.    Checking of inconsistency in the use of pronoun by students
f.     Giving number inconsistency in the use of pronoun by students
g.    Classifying of students’ mistake
h.    Concluding of inconsistency in the use of pronoun
2.    Describing  the Data
The researcher describes the parallel structure errors found in students’ essay.
3.    Interpreting the Data
In interpreting the data, the researcher will score the percentage of students’ scores in parallel structure errors found in students’ essays. The researcher will use the formula as proposed by Anas (1996:40) as follows:
P =
Where: P = percentage
                         F = frequency
                         N = number of sample